I never like giving a bad rating. Fits all my shoes perfectly! Overall, its really good! The best part is the wireless feature. regardless. I will say, they are not the most comfortable and are a bit stiff when you first wear them. So, you need the charger with you at all times to re-dock them and keep them off, and it is a little bulky/heavy always having it in your pocket if you are just heading to the store for 30 minutes but dont want to be rude to the cashier leaving them in while checking out. I received hardware that had an aluminum block with a threaded hole so close to the edge there was no structure to it at all. These are extremely well made and high quality, and they charge via USB. The finish on these boots is nubuck and they are a great tawny mid-brown that I have always referred to as English tan.